Dec 13, 2010

Lee Smolin’s trouble with physics and fractal spacetime.

13th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 56

Lee Smolin’s trouble with physics and fractal spacetime.

As things stand at this point in time, Prof. Lee Smolin is probably the most influential scientist in theoretical physics. Smolin has a talent for both serious fundamental science as well a popular science writing in a beyond measure manner. A handful of people could be compared to Smolin’s dual role in science such as R. Penrose but then he is (wrongly) considered by physicists to be only a mathematician. His latest book which is yet again a best seller is not only worth reading for those working in E-infinity, it is a must. Another reason for discussing his book is the involvement of Prof. Lee Smolin with fractals in high energy physics in general as well as the involvement of many of his associate in the Perimeter Inst. and elsewhere with the subject of fractal spacetime.
There are countless points in Lee Smolin’s book which we would like to comment upon and therefore we have to be very choosy and concentrate on what is useful and important to E-infinity. First and foremost there is no mention what so ever of fractal spacetime in the book of Smolin. This is surprising given his documented interest in this subject. In fact there is no mention at all of the word fractal in the entire book. This could be understandable in a mathematical book where pure mathematicians exchange the word fractal with other words like foliation for instance. However Smolin’s book is a popular book and fractal is the most popular word for foliation and continuous geometry or noncommutative geometry. Even the book of Field Medalist A. Connes who is held by Smolin and our group in high esteem occasionally speaks of fractals. We very much hope that no misconception or misunderstanding has prejudiced Prof. Lee Smolin against fractal spacetime because our group needs and hopes for his scientific weight and support.
On page 313 Smolin considers the category of researcher referred to by him as seers and considers their opinion about background-independent approach. E-infinity was developed using the quantum sets methodology of D. Finkelstein. On page 322 Smolin says that D. Finkelstein is a deep thinker (a seer) who does physics differently from anyone else. He talks of the problems that people like Finkelstein would face today if they tried to get funding or a professorship like Finkelstein did. He says it would be impossible today. We in E-infinity do not care about funding or professorships. However we do care that Lee Smolin extends to our work the same tolerance he extended to Finkelstein so that we can at least see that one person, Smolin, is still conducting science ethics and science policy in the same way as in the golden age of science and physics.
On pages 245-247 Smolin gives an apt description of A. Connes and his noncommutative geometry with which we agree completely. There is only one point here. Alain Connes works is a de facto fractal universe. His work is exactly like that of Mohamed El Naschie anchored in von Neumann’s continuous geometry, K-theory and E-infinity rings and groups. On page 313 Smolin mentions the work of Fay Dowker and R. Sorkin. Well both work with partially ordered sets. In E-infinity we work with random Cantor sets. In our case we do not even need a computer to reach the same excellent results which R. Loll and J. Ambjorn reached. The work of both of these two excellent scientists is considered by L. Smolin on pages 242 and 243. Both Loll and Ambjorn worked indirectly in fractal spacetime and published many papers on that including one in Scientific American which we hoped and wished they had acknowledged our work but they did not. This is sad but everyone could overlook important papers in the heat of publication fever. It is not tragic. However and this is a most polite and respectful hint to Prof. Smolin personally……. Is it not more often the case that those who made it big often forget and do not care about those who did not yet make it that big? We remind Prof. L. Smolin of the wonderful story of A. Connes on page 275 of his wonderful book. In all fairness, with this we rest our case, at least here.
E-infinity Group.
P.S.
Smolin’s book is published by Penguin, England (2006). Price £25.- with £5 discount.

Crystallographic groups and Heterotic strings in E-infinity.

13th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 55

Crystallographic groups and Heterotic strings in E-infinity.

The following is a notice on a very short paper published in CS&F, 42 (2008), pp. 2282-2284. Although very short and at first glance may appear unassuming, it is extremely important to grasp the idea behind it. It is well known that there are 17 different ‘tiling’ groups in two dimensions corresponding to 17 two and three Stein spaces with total dimensions of 685. In three dimensions there are 230 groups and 219 from that correspond exactly to the 17 groups in two dimensions. The question now is how many dimensions belong to these 219? In this paper El Naschie answers this question. The answer is 8872 which is exactly the number of states of the first massless level of particle-like states of the Heterotic string theory. It is extremely interesting to see that these seemingly abstract 8872 states have such a strong and deep connection with something as real as 3D crystals.
E-infinity group.

Suslin set theoretical foundation of E-infinity theory

12th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 54

Suslin set theoretical foundation of E-infinity theory

Descriptive set theory which forms an important basis and deep theoretical underpinning of E-infinity theory was the joint discovery of Nikolai Luzin, the real founder of the famous Moscow School of Mathematics and a young brilliant student of his, Mikhail Suslin in the summer of 1916. In fact there is a birth certificate for this theory with both Luzin and Suslin as parents and no one less than the famous Polish mathematician Waclaw Sierpinski (the father of the Sierpinski fractal triangle or gasket) was a witness. The certificate is dated the afternoon of October 1916 but no day is given. There is a serious reason for this joke. It seems that P.S. Alexandrov, the great Russian topologist whose work on wild topology combining topology with Cantor sets (which is crucial to El Naschie’s E-infinity) wanted to claim Luzin and Suslin’s discovery for himself. Alexandrov was a great mathematician and was actually a very close friend of P. Urysohn whose dimensional theory is about the most important thing in E-infinity theory. Never the less it seems Alexandrov had a character deficiency. Dishonesty among the greatest of scientists seems to be as old as the history of science and it is still with us today. There are far worse plagiarists than this and far more famous scientific disputes engulfing as famous people as Newton versus Leipnitz, Einstein versus Poincaré as well as Lorenz and even D. Hilbert and so on and so on. This is extremely sad but it is fact. Great minds do not always necessarily imply great characters. Scientists are only human and sometimes very human.
A good place to start studying descriptive set theory is to start with trees and trees on products. After that we have to concentrate on polish spaces. The most important examples of polish spaces for E-infinity are the n-dimensional cube studied by M. El Naschie and the Hilbert cube studied by Ji-Huan He. After that comes the Cantor space used in several papers by El Naschie on E-infinity and descriptive set theory, all published in CS&F. Finally we should mention the Bair space. In E-infinity ordinary differentiation and integration are replaced by Weyl scaling while Suslin scaling is used as a fundamental operation on sets. These things sound more difficult than they are and in praxis the situation is much simpler when we are dealing with a concrete problem. Finally we should mention that E-infinity may be regarded as a space made of a Borel set. El Naschie repeatedly mentioned that this idea was given without any mathematics at all by the very great theoretical physicist J.A. Wheeler. El Naschie did not do more than adding the mathematics using random Cantor sets with golden mean Hausdorff dimension.
E-infinity group.

The first E8 proposal for complete unification of all fundamental forces

12th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 53

The first E8 proposal for complete unification of all fundamental forces

It is abundantly clear from a quick study of the large body of literature published by Mohamed El Naschie, Ji-Huan He, L. Marek-Crnjac and many of those working on E-infinity theory that the first implicit proposal for unification using E8 exceptional Lie group was published around 2005 or even earlier. The exact date needs time to nail down more accurately because of the large volume of papers by the prolific author. In a paper entitled “Determining the number of Hiss particles starting from general relativity and various other field theories” which was published in CS&F, 23, (2005), pp. 711-725 El Naschie set outs to explain the idea of unification in paragraph 11 which is labeled Discussion and Conclusion on pages 724 and 725.
In what follows we give a summary of what was said on this subject. At that time El Naschie chose to call his idea, conservation of the dimensional symmetry. He wrote that in what was a rudimentary form simply equating Dim E8E8 to N(R(8)) plus alpha bar naught of electromagnetism, that is to say 137 plus N(R(4)). With R(8) he means the number of independent components of a Riemannian tensor in eight dimensions. These are 336 before compactification and 338.885438, nearly equal 339 after compactification. They are the net difference between the compactified dimensions of E8E8, namely 496 ̶ k2 = 495.9674775 and the compactified dimensions of E6E6 which are equal to 156 + 6k = 157.0820393 when symmetry is broken and E8E8 goes to E6E6 of the exceptional E-line of those important Lie symmetry groups. It is historically interesting to note that at this time El Naschie did not use ‘t Hooft’s holographic boundary where all the 339 particles of the 496 bulk lives. Thus El Naschie used a kind of super gravity argument at that time. He then adds the usual 20 representing the independent components of the Einstein gravity. There are exactly 20 for the case of four dimensions. Thus he has in essence equated the 496 dimensions of the E8E8 bulk with N(R(8)) plus alpha bar naught of electromagnetism plus N(R(4)) = 339 + 137 + 20. This is exactly equal 496 when we consider the integer approximation. In later publications the said 20 were interpreted as the number of isometries of pure gravity in 8 dimensions and the 339 as the number of elementary particles living on the holographic boundary. This is a real unification attempt using the E8E8 group and is many years before any similar attempt by anyone and definitely years before G. Lisi. It is also interesting to note that calculation without compactification leading to 336 instead of 339 particles was interpreted in this particular article as suggesting the existence of 3 Higgs particles H(+), H( ̶ ) and H(0) to make up the deficit of 339 ̶ 336 = 3. El Naschie for some reason never repeated this interesting interpretation again as far as we are aware.

Peter Woit “Not Even Wrong” is certainly right and wrong: An interview with Mohamed El Naschie

12th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 52

Peter Woit “Not Even Wrong” is certainly right and wrong: An interview with Mohamed El Naschie

The following is a summary of an interview with Prof. Mohamed El Naschie conducted by Shayma, a journalist based in Cairo which will be published in full length in Arabic.
Dr. Woit’s book (published by Jonathan Cape, London (2006)) is an excellent popular account voicing strong dissent against the dominance of string theory. Never the less we think super strings are a very useful theory which has made and it still making important contributions. Dr. Woit made several important remarks and suggestions towards improving the standard model of high energy physics and reaching the number one goal of theoretical physics at present which is quantum gravity, i.e. unifying quantum mechanics and general relativity in one coherent and consistent theory. Other important aspects of modern quantum physics were omitted all together such as fractal spacetime and fractal gravity or addressed briefly and superficially like noncommutative geometry. Let us commence with the positive aspects of this important book which we believe should be read by every scientist working on modern physics.
The crucial point which Woit makes is related to the role of symmetry in quantum mechanics. He spells it out already in the introduction at the end of page 7 where he writes “The failure of the superstring theory programme can be traced to its lack of any fundamental new symmetry principle”. He then continues on page 8 by writing “…. Advances are only likely to come about if theoretist turn their attention away from this failed programme and (direct) it towards the difficult task of better understanding the symmetries of the natural world.” It is important to carefully analyze these statements of Woit summarizing all the wisdom of his book. To be sure, superstrings are making use of a very important symmetry principle which is new in physics although well known for a long time in mathematics, namely the exceptional Lie symmetry group E8. In fact superstrings take E8 E8 with dimension equal (2)(dim E8) = (20)(248) – 496. Thus this is not what Woit means. What we think he means is a completely new symmetry better suited to quantum gravity. Maybe he also means a larger group which is richer than E8. However E8 is the largest except for the monster group which is hardly understood as physics in general. If that is what Woit means then he should become a great friend of E-infinity theory and of Prof. El Naschie, that is if he took the time to read our work carefully and without prejudice. In E-infinity El Naschie, He, Crnjac and Iovane introduced much larger Lie symmetry groups than E8 by summing over all Lie symmetry groups. For instance the sum over the E-line gives a ‘fuzzy’ group, i.e. a ‘fractal’ group with 548 instead of only 496 as integer part of the dimension. During the 80’s and 90’s of the last century in what is now called the European Journal of Physics, El Naschie wrote several papers on ‘average’ symmetries. This symmetry is the symmetry of chaos and avoids the anomalies stemming from the clashes between external and internal symmetries. All that is discussed in many papers by El Naschie, particularly those related to knot theory, wild topology, von Neumann’s continuous geometry, K-theory and especially A. Connes’s noncommutative geometry and even the monster group. Woit repeats his important point regarding symmetry in the conclusion on page 266 where he write “I see as an important lesson that each generation of physicist since the advent of quantum mechanics seems to need to learn anew. This lesson is the importance of symmetry principles expressed in mathematical language of group representation theory…… The underlying source of the problems of superstring theory is that the theory is not built on a fundamental symmetry principle or expressed within the language of representation theory.” We in E-infinity theory fully endorse this point of view and believe that our reformulation of Feynman’s summing over paths theory to summing over dimensions and summing over Lie groups as well as two and three Stein spaces is the correct strategy and as such is in full harmony with the views expressed in Woit’s book.
Now we come to the point upon which we do not agree at all with Woit. E-infinity is a K-theory for spacetime. In less formal mathematical language we mainly use semi groups (being summed over groups). In popular language of computer science, we use fractal automaton. Fractal sets and K-theory are what noncommutative geometry is all about. Noncommutative geometry is not as popular as string theory. However this is not the mistake of noncommutative geometry as Woit very well knows. For this reason it is not adequate to give only a few lines in his book to noncommutative geometry. On page 256 Woit write “One other speculative research programme that deserves mention goes under the name of non-commutative geometry….”. We in E-infinity profoundly disagree. If you call noncommutative geometry speculative, what do you call superstrings with 10 spacetime dimensions of which we have only seen 3 and God knows what the fourth or the fifth could be. A. Connes is the most important mathematician alive working in physics besides Sir. R. Penrose. We are astonished about this evaluation of Woit for noncommutative geometry for another reason. In his Acknowledgement Dr. Woit thanks Sr. R. Penrose for critical help. But one of the most important and most famous contributions of Penrose is his well known Penrose tiling. This tiling is the best known example of a noncommutative space based on K-theory and it is the prototype of E-infinity space. On piece of interesting information mentioned in Woit’s book which most of us did not know is that E. Witten has no degree, not even a Bachelors in physics. He was a journalist but his father worked in relativity and was a professor. This speaks of course for Witten. However some silly people hold it against El Naschie that he is a structural engineer and has no degree in physics.
We sincerely hope there will be a new edition of Woit’s book and that noncommutative geometry, fractal spacetime and Penrose tiling will be given more attention. There are many papers published on Elsevier’s Science Direct in CS&F regarding Penrose tiling as an example for E-infinity and noncommutative geometry of which we recommend the following:
1. M.S. El Naschie: von Neumann geometry and E-infinity quantum spacetime. CS&F, Vol. 9(12), (1998), pp. 2023-2030.
2. M.S. El Naschie: Penrose universe and Cantorian spacetime as a model for noncommutative quantum geometry. CS&F, Vol. 9(6), (1998), pp. 931-933.
3. M.S. El Naschie: Penrose tiling, semi conduction and Cantorian 1/fa spectra in four and five dimensions. CS&F, Vol. 3(4), (1993), pp. 498-491.
In addition an important paper on average symmetry is
4. M.S. El Naschie: Average exceptional Lie and Coxeter group hierarchies with special reference to the standard model of high energy particle physics. CS&F, 37, (2008), pp. 662-668.

Dec 10, 2010

The quantum sets of D. Finkelstein, E-infinity sets and the paper of D. Benedetti

10th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 51

The quantum sets of D. Finkelstein, E-infinity sets and the paper of D. Benedetti

Prof. David Ritz Finkelstein is one of the earliest pioneers of quantum set and the construction of spacetime in a way similar to deriving thermodynamics from the motion of atoms. This is the original idea of El Naschie’s work which he acknowledges to have taken over from Finkelstein and Wizecker. Finkelstein is a deep thinker who was described in one of the acclaimed books of Lee Smolin as one of the seers in science today. The monad of Finkelstein space is the null set. The null here is not the dimension and we can consider his null set to be our null set as well as our empty set. We recall that E-infinity follows Suslin set theory and constructs everything from a Suslin tree starting with the empty set, the null set and the unity set. In E-infinity these are ( ̶ 1, ϕ2), (0, ϕ) and (1, 1). We note that in E-infinity we have Mandelbrot-El Naschie notion of the degrees of emptiness of an empty set leading to the totally empty set ( ̶ ∞, 0). The monad of E-infinity is random Cantor sets in general. Monad in the terminology of ‘t Hooft are called the building blocks of spacetime. ‘t Hooft does not work with sets. However a scientist somewhat close to him and very close to Prof. R. Loll, namely Prof. Fay Dowker works with partially ordered sets as explained in earlier communications. The work by D. Finkelstein was developed considerably by Heinrich Saller (see Quantum space-time-gravity by J. Baugh, D. Finkelstein, M. Shiri-Garakani and H. Saller). A particularly good summary of D. Finkelstein’s pioneering work is “Quantum sets and Clifford algebras”, Int. J. of Theoretical Physics, Vol. 21, No. 6/7 (1982). In the abstract of this paper Finkelstein says “… Quantum set theory may be applied to a quantum time space and quantum automaton.” In the introduction of his lecture in the presence of Feynman and Wheeler he said “several of us here including Feynman, Fredkin, Kantor, Moussouris, Perti, Wheeler and Zuse suggest that the universe may be discrete rather than continuous and more like a digital than analog computer. C.C. von Weizaecker (the student of Heisenberg and the elder brother of the past President of the Federal Republic of Germany) worked this path since the early 1950’s and we have recently benefitted from the relevant work of J. Ford (Ford was an expert in deterministic chaos and together with two of El Naschie’s friends, J. Casati and B. Cherekov pioneered the science of quantum chaos which is sometimes confused with the theory of Cantorian-fractal spacetime).
In the rest of this communication we address the technical aspect of E-infinity and show how to derive all the results of the work of D. Dario Benedetti from first principles in a far simpler and transparent manner using E-infinity. It is difficult to do this without writing equations but we will try our best.
First we consider our Cantorian E-infinity spacetime to be the union of infinitely many elementary monads Cantor sets. A single random Cantor set has, by the theorem of Mauldin-Williams, a Hausdorff dimension equal to the golden mean. The higher order Cantor sets will have a Hausdorff dimension equal ϕ to the power of n where n is 0, 1, 2… Adding all these dimensions together one finds the finite dimension of the large Cantorian space. Thus from summing from zero to infinity of ϕ to the power n, one finds 1 + ϕ + ϕ2 + ϕ3 + … and so on to infinity. The sum is exactly equal 2 + ϕ. This corresponds in the Connes-El Naschie dimensional function or bijection to a Menger-Urysohn dimension of exactly 3. However this has not been gauged in terms of the original monad ϕ. Therefore we have to divide 2 + ϕ by ϕ and this gives us the famous dimension 4.23606799 which corresponds exactly to the Menger-Urysohn topological dimension equal to 4. To show that 2 + ϕ corresponds to the topological dimension of 3 we just exclude the non-fractal dimension 1 from our summing. That means we start from n = 1 to n = ∞. That way the total dimensions become 2 + ϕ ̶ 1 = 1 + ϕ. To obtain the gauged dimension we divide by ϕ and find 2 + ϕ again which means the topological dimension is 3. Thus we have obtained from first principles the 4 and 3 dimensions of spacetime and space only with a single assumption which is that the union of all the elementary monads represents our spacetime. The monads themselves are formed by intersections of two and more monads. Unlike other theories our monads are explicit and well defined. They are random Cantor sets. The zero set for instance is given by two dimensions. First the topologically invariant Menger-Urysohn dimension is zero and second the Hausdorff-fractal dimension which is in this case ϕ. Thus the zero set is fixed by (0, ϕ). Using a simple elementary cobordism argument for (0, ϕ), the neighborhood or border is a wave given by the empty set ( ̶ 1, ϕ2). We could go on that way indefinitely. That means we have ( ̶ 2, ϕ3), ( ̶ 3, ϕ4) and finally (0, ̶ ∞) as mentioned earlier on. In fact we can determine the world sheet of fractal string theory. We did that when we summed from n = 1 to n = ∞ and found the total Hausdorff dimension to be 2 + ϕ ̶ 1 = 1 + ϕ. This corresponds in the Connes-El Naschie dimensional function bijection to a two dimensional object. The fractal world sheet is topologically two dimensions but Hausdorffly more than one dimensional and less than two dimensions. It is a fractal area-like with a Hausdorff fractal dimension equal 1 + ϕ = 1.618033989.
In fundamental scientific research there are two directions. We either keep improving and even patching and fixing our older theories or we start afresh from different or slightly different basic assumptions and principles. E-infinity is the second possibility. Dario Benedetti is the usual first possibility. Einstein’s relativity and quantum mechanics as well as string theory and loop quantum gravity started as the second possibility like E-infinity. In fact ‘t Hooft’s quantum field theory started exactly as E-infinity theory. Now string theory and quantum field theory are the establishment and the improvements and patching are characteristic for these important developments. In real life we need both methods and both philosophies. When we reach the same conclusions, this is then the promised land.
E-infinity group.

The placebo effect in mainstream physics

10th December, 2010.

E-infinity Communication No. 50

The placebo effect in mainstream physics

The violent effect of the establishment against new ideas is well documented and historically well researched. E-infinity has experience just such a violent effect only on the internet which gives perverted maniacs the same voice as anyone and may even be hired by sinister forces to silence competition. This is definitely the same with certain blogs hired in the north of Germany as well as a small neighbor country to scandalize as far as India and China. This possibility did not exist at the time of Einstein’s relativity and his Nazi opponents, some of whom were Nobel Laureates. Seen in this way the hired, as distinct from the real scientific opposition against E-infinity is harmless compared to that against Einstein’s relativity (see for instance the article in Physics World, April 2003).
The main reason in modern times for the rejection of a theory and unfair competition is funding money. String theoreticians may be excused for thinking that the book of Peter Woit “Not even wrong” in which he attacks string theory on all levels may have been written on the instigation of the leading scientist working in loop quantum gravity. We venture no opinion on this particular case but we think that as far as the young, innocent, unsuspecting scientists go, the problem may be related to a form of placebo effect. You expect that a theory or a scientist is bad because your supervisor told you so, then you find it bad. On the contrary, if you are told by your supervisor, or thesis advisor or Editor-in-Chief of a journal that a theory or a scientist is pure genius, then you will find it really pure genius. This is exactly the placebo effect in scientific research. Please think about it.
E-infinity Group.

The stationary states of quantum mechanics and the golden mean in E-infinity

10th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 49

The stationary states of quantum mechanics and the golden mean in E-infinity

The stationary point in classical mechanics is well known. A complete classification was given long ago in the work of Andrenov which was frequently used by M.S. El Naschie and J.M.T. Thompson in their work on stability theory, theory of bifurcation and René Thom’s catastrophe theory. For details see El Naschie’s book “Stress, stability and chaos in structural engineering – An energy approach”, McGraw Hill, London (1990) as well as Thompson’s “Instabilities and castrophies in science and engineering”, John Wiley, Chichester (1982). However something was overlooked for which Sir James Lighthill (who had a very high regard for M.S. El Naschie and who helped to establish Chaos, Solitons & Fractals) had to apologize publicly to the public at large in an article published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society. Sir James said that by overlooking the generic chaotic nature of classical mechanics and letting so many people wrongly believe for such a long time that classical mechanics is generically deterministic, the community of theoretical and applied mechanics, of which he was the Head at the time (IUTAM President), misled the educated society at large. Five major discoveries were made through the revolution of deterministic chaos.
First the work of E. Lorenz established the one additional missing attractor of classical mechanics, namely the so called strange attractor. The great German chaos scientist Otto Rössler simplified the attractor of Lorenz. Rössler’s attractor is besides the Lorenz attractor, one of the main paradigms of chaos. Second the discovery of universalities in chaos by Mitchell Feigenbaum which extended original earlier work by S. Grossmann. Third the mathematical theory of turbulence and strange attractors of D. Ruelle and F. Takens. Fourth period 3 implies chaos by J. York who found that a single Cantor set is the backbone of all complex strange attractors and chaotic behavior and finally B. Mandelbrot who gave the correct geometry of deterministic chaos. This geometry is fractals. Again fractals is what the great G. Cantor saw with his inner eyes as the geometry of his Cantor set and the related gallery of monsters as H. Poincaré described them. All these strange attractors belong to dissipative dynamics. However what about Hamiltonian systems? These systems are more relevant to quantum mechanics. Seeing a connection between chaos in Hamiltonian systems and quantum mechanics was the achievement of René Thom and applying it to high energy physics and the mass spectrum of elementary particles was the achievement of Mohamed El Naschie and E-infinity theory. Making a great deal of bad jokes and running obscene blogs about non-science is the anti-achievement of those who do not tire from wasting their lives on defamatory allegations against E-infinity and those working in our group. At a minimum this shows the low self esteem of these internet characters who are so thick skinned that they force themselves on society just because the internet tolerates almost anything and any ignoramus.
In what follows we give briefly the most important points about the VAK in quantum mechanics and E-infinity theory:
1. The KAM nested concentric tori complex picture which Poincaré was reluctant to draw in 1899 is exactly that which R Thom proposed in 1975 as the Hamiltonian analogy of the strange attractor in differential dynamics. It was later on named the VAK. Like all fractals the VAK is almost self-similar. If one small VAK inside a large VAK is enlarged, we find another VAK in it and so on like a solenoid. In infinite dimensions as in E-infinity theory the VAK vague stability is due to the irrationality of the KAM orbits and may be used according to R. Thom as a model for the stable states of quantum mechanics.
2. Influenced by the thinking of René Thom, Mohamed El Naschie used to say in his numerous lectures which he gave in the last twenty years in Germany, Italy, Spain and particularly Egypt and Saudi Arabia “Descartes explained everything using his vortices and hooked atoms but could calculate nothing; Newton calculated everything using his inverse square law but could explain nothing. Only a geometrical theory like Einstein’s theory, string theory or E-infinity theory could explain and compute almost everything.
3. The vague attractor was studied by Kolmogorov, Moser and Arnold and that is why it is called KAM or VAK. The golden mean is easily shown to be to the most irrational number because in a continued fraction we have only the smallest non-zero integer, namely one. Consequently the golden mean is the worst irrational number which could be approximated by a rational number and that explains the stability of any periodic orbit with the golden mean winding number against perturbation.
4. The infinite complexity of geometrical form is reminiscent of the paradoxical notion of quantum field theory where the energy density of the vacuum is infinite.
5. The onset of turbulence is characterized by the replacement of a vague attractor of a Hamiltonian dynamics with finite-dimensional pseudo group of symmetries by a large ergodic set similar to a Cantor set. Thus we must distinguish two types of catastrophe point, the ordinary catastrophe and the second type of open, chaotic set with the complicated topology of a Cantor set. This second type is what is the case for noncommutative geometry and E-infinity theory.
6. We emphasize one more the wide spread misconception that Cantor sets and fractals appear only at the Planck length and Planck energy. The work of people as well established as ‘t Hooft and Lee Smolin as well as young otherwise excellent researchers such as Dario Benedetti all suffer from this misconception. Fractals have very little to do with Wheeler and Hawking’s foam and are not bound to the Planck energy. They appear generically even in classical systems at low energy.
7. As the level of the VAK there is no essential difference between quantum phase space, a Hilbert space or a fractal Cantorian spacetime. The excellent work of T.N. Palmer needlessly suffers from this misconception which is based on a widespread prejudice related to wrongly connecting fractals to the so called Wheeler-Hawking spacetime foam.
E-infinity group.

Fractal properties of quantum spacetime in the Perimeter Inst. of Theoretical Physics and El Naschie’s quantum group dimension

9th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 48

Fractal properties of quantum spacetime in the Perimeter Inst. of Theoretical Physics and El Naschie’s quantum group dimension

Dario Benedetti of the Perimeter Institute, partly founded due to the efforts of Prof. Lee Smolin, published a highly interesting paper in 2009 which is quite revealing. In this paper he seems to have carefully studied the literature used mainly by the E-infinity group, for instance what Mohamed El Naschie calls the Biedenharn conjecture. Benedetti’s paper is freely available on the net “Fractal properties of quantum spacetime”, arXiv: 0811.1396V2[hep-th], 25th March 2009. The main conclusion is that taking certain limits the dimensionality of spacetime, namely exact 4 as well as space only, namely exactly 3 may be obtained using quantum groups is obtained. To show how this follows immediately from a well known quantum group dimension when setting the monadic dimension of the atoms of the concerned space we do not need much nor even referring to old papers published by Mohamed El Naschie in many international journals. All what one needs is to go through the following steps.
Step one is to take any good book on quantum groups, for instance C. Kassel book “Quantum Groups” published by Springer 1995. Step two open page 364 and there you will find a formula for quantum dimension for a simple model given explicitly to be the said monade q to the power of n + 1 minus the same but with negative power ( ̶ n ̶ 1) then all divided by q minus the inverse of q. Setting the monade q = ϕ = the quantum dimension is found to be exactly 4. One could find the result of all dimensions, namely the space dimension 3 as well as the Hausdorff dimension 4.2367977 and R. Loll’s spectral dimension 4.01999 ≃ 4.02 in a similarly very simple way. Philosophical discussion of these dimensions were given by El Naschie in a paper written when he was in Cambridge, UK in 1998 (see Bio systems (an Elseiver journal), No. 46 (1998), pp. 4-46). This paper was entitled Dimensional symmetry breaking, information and fractal gravity in Cantorian space. A second paper is in a book published by Gordon and Breach “The quest for a unified theory of information”, Edited by Wolfgang Hofkirchner. The shortest and most condensed paper is “Quantum groups and Hamiltonian sets on nuclear spacetime Cantorian manifold” in CS&F, Vol. 10, No. 7, (1999), pp. 125-1256. In particular Table No. 1 compares all the various relevant dimensions. It is important to see how completely different theories lead to essentially similar conclusions. The only question is what is the most simple theory. We have no doubt that it is E-infinity because it is free from traditions and is obliged only to the mathematical logic with no regard to the political correctness of scientific grouping and science funding policy.
E-infinity group.

The role of dissipation in the ‘t Hooft-El Naschie-Ord quantum systems

9th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 47
The role of dissipation in the ‘t Hooft-El Naschie-Ord quantum systems
Almost all realistic engineering systems have friction losses or any other kind of dissipation. As a structural engineer and applied mechanics scientist El Naschie dealt as long ago as 1976 with nonconservative, dissipative mechanical systems. In his paper in ‘Solid Mechanics Archives, Vol. 4, August 1979 (published by Stijthoff & Noordhoff Int. Publishers, Holland) he developed a finite element-like method (finite element is the engineer’s version of Regge calculus of general relativity). The method he employed, invented by Belgian engineer van den Dungen (Bull. Acad. Ray Belg. Sci Ser 1945 (31), pp. 659-668) consists of joining two dissipative systems, one with energy losses and another with energy gain (a so called flutter set), balancing each other and thus forming a conservative Hamiltonian system. In a paper published in 1995 in CS&F entitled “A note on quantum mechanics, diffusional interference and information” he extended his two dissipative systems forming one conservative system idea to the Schrödinger equation by two conjugate complex Schrödinger equations, one going forwards and the other going backwards in time (see CS&F, 5(5), pp. 881-884 (1995)). The importance of this paper was immediately recognized by Prof. G. Ord whose model is essentially very similar although it may not seem to be that way without careful examination. It all boiled down to the need for an additional negative sign which will become apparent later on. It could be that the Nobel Laureate became quite interested in nonlinear dynamics which always includes dissipation and a dissipative ‘strange attractor’ after meeting El Naschie on several occasions around the year 2000 including a conference in Riyadh and another in Cairo. It is clear that ‘t Hooft must have been thinking about these things for some time before that because he realized that the notion of time in relativity is fundamentally different from that in quantum mechanics and because he had a controversy with Steven Hawkings about the information paradox of black holes. Ultimately ‘t Hooft wrote several papers connecting the loss of information with dissipation and applied that to a new quantum mechanics which he called deterministic quantum mechanics. Similar to E-infinity ‘t Hooft used fluid turbulence as a paradigm for his theory. However at that time ‘t Hooft new nothing about quasi attractors in Hamiltonian systems because the VAK (the vague attractor of Kolmogorov) was not yet recognized by Mohamed El Naschie and thus not yet incorporated into his work. The VAK first conjectured as the stationary states of quantum mechanics by French topologist and the inventor of catastrophe theory, Rene Thom was considered much later (see for instance the paper “Strange non-dissipative and non-chaotic attractors and Palmer’s deterministic quantum mechanics” by G. Iovane and S. Nada published in CS&F, 42, pp 641-642 (2009).

Part II of communication No. 47
It is important to realize that although the VAK has no physical friction to give it stability, it has a mathematical substitute for the lack of friction, namely the irrationality of the winding number. Noting that the golden mean is the most irrational number, it follows that a golden mean winding number is the most stable orbit for a dynamic system and that is the reason why the mass of the elementary particles which could realistically be observed experimentally is always a function of the golden mean and its power. This also follows from von Neumann-Connes’ dimensional function. Dimensions are related to the coupling constant and these are in turn related to energy and thus the mass of elementary particles. In 2007 M. El Naschie gave a Lagrangian formulation to his basic 1979 idea in a paper entitled “On gauge invariance, dissipative quantum mechanics and self-adjoint sets. The paper was dedicated to his by that time very close friend Gerard ‘t Hooft in celebration of his 60th birthday (see CS&F, 32 (2007), pp. 271-273). In the meantime Ord refined his work by introducing the ani-Bernulli diffusion mimicking quantum mechanics (see for instance Annals of Physics, 324 (2009), pp. 1211-1218) where he refers as usual to the very same 1995 paper of El Naschie. The fact however is that all these different formulations are basically different faces of the same multi-dimensional coin. We can obtain the needed ‘negative’ sign by considering an adjoint flutter set with energy gain or a dissipative set with energy losses. We can also change a Bernulli random walk using zero and plus one to an anti-Bernulli random walk with 0, +1 and ̶ 1. We can introduce anti-commuting Grassmanian coordinates a proposed by ‘t Hooft and used in super string theory or we can go back to fundamentals and consider all the empty sets with their negative Menger-Urysohn dimensions as done by Mohamed El Naschie
E-infinity Group

The road to Nottale scale relativity and some remarks on a recent paper by Nobel Laureate G. ‘t Hooft.

8th December, 2010.

E-infinity communication No. 46

The road to Nottale scale relativity and some remarks on a recent paper by Nobel Laureate G. ‘t Hooft.

Various statements and new mathematical and physical ingredients in a relatively recent paper by Nobel Laureate G. ‘t Hooft (see Quantum gravity without space-time singularities – arXiv: 0909.3426V1[gr-qc], 18 Sept. 2009) are effectively a compliment to the work of Laurent Nottale. It is well known that Nottale is one of the first not only to appreciate the crucial role of scale invariance but also to give a general theory of relativity within a scale invariance program which is relevant to quantum and high energy physics. A very readable popular account of Nottale work may be found in “Ciel et Espace”, February (1994), pp. 28-32. The interview is entitled “Espace-Temps Fractal – La Nouvelle theorie de l’univers”. A formal introduction to Nottale’ theory including references to the work of Garnet Ord as well as Mohamed El Naschie may be found in his by now classical book “Fractal Space-Time and Microphysics”, World Scientific, Singapore (1993). Unitl recently Nottale considered his papers in CS&F to be the most up to date and comprehensive but in 2010 he has published at least two new very long papers in Springer journals which may be found on the internet, all apart from his excellent blog called “Scale Relativity Corner” where highly scientific and informative high level, civilized discussion is going on without the usual vulgarity and aggressiveness characteristic of the run of the mill pseudo scientific blogs nowadays. The idea behind Nottale’s work is basically the same as that of Ord and El Naschie although the mathematics is slightly different. The idea is as simple as it is ingenious. Some mathematical physicists call it the Biedenharn conjecture. It is the fact that any space which is a fractal is devoid of any natural scale. Consequently it is explicitly scale invariant. That means it is a gauge theory in the original sense of the work of H. Weyl. This is the reason by Mohamed El Naschie replaces calculus by Weyl scaling. In fact this is the reason by in E-infinity we can use the set theoretical Suslin scaling. In the particular case of E-infinity theory this leads naturally to golden mean renormalization groups used so successfully by Mitchell Feigenbaum in finding his structural universalities. The pure mathematical background for these E-infinity relations may be found in the theory of semi-groups. The research related to Lucasian numbers by Hilton as well as Fibonacci groups by Nikolova is particularly interesting. It is strange, if not quite disturbing, that J.C. Baez takes such a hostile position to E-infinity theory although he occasionally works on loop spaces, E-infinity ring spaces and spectra all apart of groupoids. However maybe this aggressive rejection has a more personal than scientific basis.
In the paper of ‘t Hooft mentioned above he states already in the abstract that he “…finds that exact invariance under scale transformation is an essential new ingredient….”. Then he continues by saying “These differences can be boiled down to conformal transformation”. He points out that Newton’s constant is not scale-invariant and neither is the Einstein-Hilbert action. Consequently he cannot use the Riemann curvature nor its Ricci components. Apart of the Weyl component nothing is left except to follow the road outlines by L. Nottale, M. Agop and E. Goldfain, namely scale relativity, fractal spacetime and E-infinity transfinite sets.

Dec 8, 2010

Dial E or K for dilation and an apology to fiber bundle

7th December, 2010.
E-infinity communication No. 45

Dial E or K for dilation and an apology to fiber bundle

The present communication, not in any way related to a Hitchcock film, is a very short bird’s eye view of the connection between E-infinity and K theory as well as the relation to ‘t Hooft’s very recent dilation proposal to improve quantum field theory. We start with a short sincere apology over a hasty statement made with regard to the theory of fiber bundles in a communication related to the new Lisi paper in Scientific American, December 2010. In the communication we wrote that fiber bundles are neither fish nor meat. This was an unnecessarily harsh statement and what is worse, it is incorrect and worse still, E-infinity is a fiber bundle theory. Fiber bundles and Yang-Mill theories are extremely fundamental and this statement has to be withdrawn. It is true we live in a different world and electronic computation has revolutionized science and the methods of proof. We now have subjects like experimental mathematics as well as computer assisted proof. In the light of all of that fractals may appear to be the only way to model complex behavior in high energy physics. However fundamental thinking from which transfinite set theory and subsequently fractals were created is needed now more than ever.
Let us start by recalling some informal explanation for what K-theory is. It is a devise by which one examines mathematical structures such as rigs or topological spaces via a parameterized vector space. In particular A. Grothendick initiated the subject by extending a theorem well known in the theory of 4-manifold namely the Riemann-Roch theorem. We may recall that M.S. El Naschie as well as C. Castro considered this theorem in connection with their research on E-infinity theory. Very loosely speaking much of the work on K-theory is a generalization of Riemann-Roch theorem to a theory of indexes as shown in the work of Sir M. Atiyah and E. Hirzebruch. In fact Mohamed El Naschie’s interest in K-theory stems from a meeting with Prof. Sir. M. Atiyah in the year 2000. In a Cairo conference organized by the Egyptian Mathematical Society Sir Atiyah gave the opening lecture followed by Prof. El Naschie’s second invited lecture which was on Cantorian-fractal spacetime. The discussion between Sir Atiyah and Prof. El Naschie continued the next day in the evening at the home of the Minister of Industry, Prof. Dr. Ibrahim Fawzi. The lecture of Sir Atiyah is contained in the Proceedings published by World Scientific (2001), Edited by A. Ashour and A. Obada, the two Chairmen of the conference and is entitled “Mathematics and the 21st century”.
Coming back to ‘t Hooft’s paper “The conformal constraint in canonical quantum gravity” it seems that to include the fractal-like dilaton field he had to consider a flat Kaluza-Klein space. This is the idea of the Finish G. Nordström who according to a paper by Prof. El Naschie published in CS&F, proposed the fifth dimension before T. Kaluza and of course before O. Klein. In addition a vanishing beta function became necessary. Again the role of beta function in E-infinity was discussed in one of El Naschie’s rare publications on quantum field theory. In doing all that ‘t Hooft was hoping that the landscape of his quantum field became denumerable. In the nonlinear science terminology of E-infinity this means make it countable infinity instead of uncountably infinite. Once more we must recall that the landscape of E-infinity or the infinitely many ground states can all be summed exactly as shown in two papers by El Naschie published in CS&F, one of them entitled “On the universality class of all universality classes and E-infinity spacetime physics”.
Finally we may point out that the dimensional function of von Neumann and Connes used by El Naschie in the form of his bijection formula and the golden mean average theorem may be regarded very loosely as an index theorem of K-theory. The same may be said also very loosely and informally about El Naschie’s Cantorian spacetime and Penrose tessellation for being based on K-theory.
E-infinity Group.

P.S.: Relevant literature:-
1. M.S. El Naschie: Penrose universe and Cantorian spacetime as a model for noncommutative quantum geometry Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, Vol. 9(6), (1998), pp. 931-933.
2. M.S. El Naschie: Quantum Groups and Hamiltonian Sets on a Nuclear Spacetime Cantorian Manifold Chaos, Solitons, & Fractals, Vol. 10(7), (1999), pp. 1251-1256.
3. M.S. El Naschie: A Note on Quantum Field Theory and P-brans in Dimensions Chaos, Solitons, & Fractals, Vol. 10(8), (1999), pp. 1413-1417.
4. A. Mukhamedov: E-infinity as a fiber bundle and its thermodynamics, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 33, (2007), pp. 717-724.
5. M.S. El Naschie: On the universality class of all universality classes and E-infinity spacetime physics, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 32, (2007), pp. 927-936.
6. M.S. El Naschie: On the topological ground state of E-infinity spacetime and the super string connection Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, Vol. 32(2), (2007), pp. 468-470.

Schrödinger’s cat meets Arnold’s cat in El Naschie’s infinity garden

E-infinity communication No. 44

Schrödinger’s cat meets Arnold’s cat in El Naschie’s infinity garden.

No one knows exactly why E. Schrödinger the Austrian Nobel Laureate in physics and founder of wave mechanics chose a cat to subject to a most cruel type of quantum measurement. The reasons for the Russian V. Arnold, probably one of the greatest mathematicians of all time to deform a cat’s picture beyond recognition using his well known map are even less clear. In all events both cats are alive, well and jumping in E-infinity’s golden garden. The two eigenvalues of Arnold’s cat map happened to be the inverse of the golden mean (1/ϕ) = 1 + ϕ and the inverse of the golden mean squared (1/ϕ)2 = 2 + ϕ. Now adding both values or multiplying them gives exactly the very same result, namely (1 + ϕ) + (2 + ϕ) = 4.23606799 and (1 + ϕ) (2 + ϕ) = 4.23606799. In other words union and intersection of the two transfinite sets gives the same result. One can easily see that the first set have the topological dimension of an area just like a world sheet in string theory. This area has a fractal dimension equal 1 + ϕ = 1.61833989. The second set on the other hand is topologically three dimensional, however its Haudorff dimension is 2 + ϕ = 2.168033989. Topologically the union of the two sets is 2 + 3 = 5 dimensional. However seen from the Hausdorff dimension view point, the two sets give a dimension equal 4 + ϕ3 = 4.23606799 which corresponds to exactly 4 and only 4 topological dimensions. In other words one topological dimension is hidden. The 5 dimensions are used only for embedding the 4.23606799 fractal dimension. On the other hand we know very well that 2 + ϕ = 2.61803389 corresponds exactly to 3 topological dimensions of the tangible world. The only thing left for interpretation is that 1 + ϕ which is topologically 2 dimensional is that these two dimensions stand for time and the spin ½ fermionic dimension or alternatively for the fifth Kaluza-Klien compactified or the cyclic dimension of electromagnetism.
The reader is referred to the following paper for simple geometrical visualization of the Russian doll-like E-infinity space with 4.23606799 Hausdorff dimension corresponding to exactly only 4 topological Menger-Urysohn dimensions. See for instance “An irreducibly simple derivation of the Hausdorff dimension of spacetime”, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 41, (2009), pp. 1902-1904, particularly Table 1 on page 1903. See also “The theory of Cantorian spacetime and high energy particle physics (an informal review)”, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 41 (2009), pp. 2635-2646, in particular Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 on pages 2636 and 2639 respectively.
It remains to say that it is the fine structure of fractals contributing 0.23606799 = ϕ3 where ϕ is the golden mean = 0.618033989 which causes the equality of union and intersection of the Cantor sets spanning E-infinity spacetime and leading to the infinite but hierarchal dimensionality of this fractal Cantorian spacetime manifold which is the cause of the persistent illusion that a quantum object on a fractal particle can be said to be in two different spacetime fractal ‘points’ at the very same fractal ‘time’. Looked upon it from a distance, this intricate non-smooth and chaotic Cantorian-fractal spacetime appears smooth with only four spacetime topological dimensions. To show this in the most clear quantative way we just need to approximate the irrational number to the simplest rational number. That means 2 + ϕ = 2.618033 will be 2.5 = 5/2 and 1 + ϕ = 1.618033 will be 1.5 = 3/2. Adding together we find 2.5 + 1.5 = 4. On the other hand multiplication leads to a different dimension known from the theory of dimensional regularization, namely (5/2)(3/2) = 3.75 = 4 ̶ 0.25. This corresponds in E-infinity to 4 ̶ k where k = 0.18033989 of the transfinite Heterotic super string theory. It is vital to recall the importance of Arnold’s cat map in the study of quantum chaos as well as the discussion of the role of irrational numbers in combined harmonic oscillators by Prof. G. ‘t Hooft in his paper mentioned in an earlier communication “The mathematical basis for deterministic quantum mechanics”. In fact on page 7 of the arXiv paper he writes “….If the frequencies have an irrational ratio (which in the terminology of El Naschie and nonlinear dynamics means irrational winding number), the period of the classical system is infinite and so a continuous spectrum would be expected.” Sooner or later we are confident that those working in quantum field theory and have come as far as this will realize that K-theory, noncommutative geometry and E-infinity is the right way to come to what Nobel Laureate ‘t Hooft hopes to find, namely some kind of deterministic quantum mechanics.
E-infinity Group.

Dec 7, 2010

‘t Hooft dilaton proposal and the inbuilt natural conformal invariance of E-infinity and Nottale scale relativity

6th December, 2010
E-infinity Communication No. 43

‘t Hooft dilaton proposal and the inbuilt natural conformal invariance of E-infinity and Nottale scale relativity

Nobel Laureate Professor Gerard ‘t Hooft is one of a handful of leading mainstream physicists who have an enduring interest in reforming quantum field theory and therefore by necessity amending the basic structure of quantum mechanics itself. This interest continued despite considerable criticism from many other leading scientists, for instance Nobel Laureate D. Gross who recently said in an article entitled “The major unknown in particle physics and cosmology” with respect to ‘t Hooft’s deterministic quantum mechanics that if we were to go back to deterministic classical theory, things would only get worse. In our view this is a total misunderstanding of what ‘t Hooft is trying to do as well as a total misunderstanding of classical mechanics. Classical mechanics is generically deterministically chaotic. In fact this is a well known result of the major work of Poincaré on the three body problems. The four body problem is even worse and at the time of writing there is no computer in the universe which is large enough to even start numerically integrating the problem of how five planets move under mutual influence. It was in fact Nobel Laureate Max Born, the teacher of Werner Heisenberg who disputed that classical mechanics is deterministic. A very readable and relatively short paper discussing the work of Max Born and contrasting ‘t Hooft’s work on deterministic quantum mechanics with Mohamed El Naschie’s work on E-infinity theory is “Deterministic quantum mechanics versus classical mechanical indeterminism”, published in Int. J. of Nonlinear Sci. & Num. Simulation, 8(1), 5-10 (2007). The article of Max Born is “Ist die Klassische Mechanik tatsächlich deterministisch?”, published in Physikalishe Blätter II, pp. 49 (1955). A second paper by El Naschie is in the same volume where Prof. ‘t Hooft’s paper is published entitled “What is quantum mechanics?”, pp. 84-102. The volume is a publication of the American Inst. of Physics, Vol. 905 (2007). El Naschie’s paper is entitled “Deterministic quantum mechanics versus classical mechanical indeterminism and nonlinear dynamics”, pp. 56-66. In our opinion the most important new developments in the work of ‘t Hooft is that he seems to have discovered fractals and consequently El Naschie’s zero and empty transfinite-fractal sets for quantum field theory. In his 2008 paper “Locally finite model for gravity”, published on arXiv: 0804.0328U1[gr-qc]2, April, 2008 he clearly says in the abstract that the model is not finite because the solutions tend to generate infinite fractals. Furthermore in Fig. 2 on page 5 his deficit and surplus angles are the reason for introducing fractal simplicticity a la Mohamed El Naschie and thus Cantor dust and fractals. In fact it is the dilaton, which is known from all superstring theories which bring the scale invariance of the fractal geometry of Nottale and El Naschie through a backdoor into ‘t Hooft’s quantum field theoretical model. He admits trouble due to the negative sign of the new field but that is a little price to pay to enter into the paradise of zero and empty transfinite-fractal sets which are the basic building blocks of spacetime and consequently of E-infinity. We hope ‘t Hooft remains in Cantor paradise with D. Hilbert.

K-theoretical foundation f E-infinity and the real meaning of counterfactuals and contexuality

6th December, 2010
E-infinity Communication No. 42
K-theoretical foundation f E-infinity and the real meaning of counterfactuals and contexuality

As the reader becomes more and more familiar with E-infinity and provided he has a strong interest in pure mathematics and set theoretical foundational work he will realize the K-theoretical origin of E-infinity theory. This should not come as a surprise to anyone who already sees E-infinity as a concrete realization of von Neumann-Connes’ noncommutative geometry. In fact there are many other unsuspected relations to E-infinity theory stemming from the relation of Yang-Mills theory and quantum gravity with the notion of connection on vector bundles. There is complete equivalence between the category of vector bundles over compact space and bundle maps as well as projective modulus of all sorts in the smooth case. They may explain the reaction of people like John Baez against E-infinity which was more elementary and easier to understand without abstract mathematics and achieved substantial and testable results in high energy physics while others, with the exception of Connes and of course Penrose were still deeply involved in abstraction. In fact much of the recent work by Nobel Laureate G. ‘t Hooft and particularly his 2006 paper “The mathematical basis for deterministic quantum mechanics”, arXiv: quant-ph/0604008V2, 26th June 2006 could be understood at least partially as translating E-infinity theory and K-theory to his language, namely the language of the very successful quantum field theory. We in E-infinity gratefully acknowledge the unique achievements of classical quantum field theory but it is time to expand this theory either piecemeal as is happening most of the time or in one great quantum jump to noncommutative geometry, E-infinity and K-theory. For instance the problem of indistinguishable large sets of quantum data forming equivalence classes is understood in E-infinity or K-theory as an algebraic K-theory analogous to topological invariant of corresponding virtual spaces and sets such as the infinitely many sets with negative Menger-Urysohn dimension and yet finite positive Hausdorff dimension. The minus one empty set for instance has a dimension equal to the golden mean in E-infinity theory as well as the K-theory of noncommutative Penrose tiling or Penrose universe as pointed out some time ago by M.S. El Naschie and Ji-Huan He. The totally empty or truly empty set at minus infinity where all kinds of geometrical objects including any Cantor set or dust disappears completely still has a non-negative Hausdorff dimension, namely exactly zero.
We note here on passing that the notion of counterfactuals was introduced to quantum mechanics only because quantum mechanics did not directly consider negative topological dimensions nor empty sets. Similarly contexuality is only the consequence of the indistinguishability between union and intersection in the basic geometrical-topological structure of a geometry which accounts not only for the zero set (0,ϕ) but also for all empty sets ( ̶ 1,ϕ2), ( ̶ 2, ϕ3), … and so on until ( ̶ ∞, 0) on a very fundamental level.
To see the connection between G. ‘t Hooft’s limit cycles given in the 2006 paper mentioned above and the work of E-infinity, the reader is advised to read in depth the paper of Mohamed El Naschie “Coupled oscillations and mode locking of quantum gravity fields, scale relativity and E-infinity space”, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 12 (2001), p. 179-192. For instance equation (7.4) on page 13 of ‘t Hooft’s paper is exactly identical to Dunkerley’s theorem of equation (10) and the elasto-plastic Rankin-Merchant formula given by equation (11) in El Naschie’s paper. Prof. El Naschie knew these equations from his research in engineering science and his work in buckling and vibration of elastic and elasto-plastic structures. We find it really fascinating how pure mathematics such as K-theory can be connected however indirectly with applied-applied engineering research while in between we have theories such as gauge theory and Yang-Mills theory. This cross fertilization is not unique to E-infinity but is very characteristic for the working of our E-infinity group.
In the next communication we will expand on all the aspects which we have only touched upon in this communication.
E-infinity Group.

Dec 5, 2010

Comments on Lisi’s new 2010 paper in Scientific American ‘The vital importance of the concept of average symmetry and summing over Lie symmetry groups

4th December, 2010.

E-infinity communication No. 41
Comments on Lisi’s new 2010 paper in Scientific American ‘The vital importance of the concept of average symmetry and summing over Lie symmetry groups

One could of course use a superficially mathematical language and terminology to suggest that Dr. G. Lisi’s work on E8 is pure numerology. For instance why E8 and why did he never mention E7. Maybe because E8 is the largest with 248 dimensions. If this is the reason then he may be mistaken because in the Max Planck Inst. for Gravitation near Berlin, Germany as well as elsewhere people have found E10 and E11. In fact there are many papers by leading mathematical physicists suggesting a relation between E11 and the eleven dimensional M-theory of E. Witten, so why not E11? This is by no means the end either. There is a well documented 12 dimensional F-theory and both American physicist Ray Munroe and Mohamed El Naschie conjectured that there may be out there a 685 dimensional E12 symmetry group. Worse still if we grant that E8 is the main relevant exceptional group, then Lisi’s work could be termed numerology because he merely fits a certain number of real or hypothetical elementary particles to certain numbers fixing the geometry and topology of E8, for instance the dimension 248 or the number of roots 240. Of course we do not view Lisi’s work in this way. We were only playing the devil’s advocate because of all the trivial and cheap charges of numerology which emanate from certain quarters for reasons best known to themselves. However it is important to emphasize the importance of super positioning many exceptional compact and non-compact Lie symmetry groups to obtain fuzzy or fractal-like larger symmetry groups which represent a symmetry on average or a real world average symmetry like the well known average symmetry of chaotic strange attractors (see for instance Symmetry in Chaos by M. Field and M. Golubitsky, Oxford (1992)). The chapter on page 27 is entitled ‘Symmetry on Average’. It is worth summarizing what the author says on pages 27-30:
“To make 100 iterations we require 5000 arithmetic computations and if we work by hand without a computer we need 3 days and this does not include plotting and colouring of the strange attractor and yet we will not observe any symmetry. The symmetry hidden in these strange attractors needs at least 1500 iterations and to see it clearly we need 60,000 iterations which is a hopeless task without a computer and that is why the concept of symmetry in chaos or average symmetry was not discovered earlier.”
One of the earliest papers on average symmetry in physics and E-infinity nonlinear dynamics was El Naschie’s 1994 paper entitled ‘Average symmetry, stability and ergodicity of multi-dimensional Cantor sets’, Il Nuovo Cimento, Vol./ 109, N.2, February (1994), p. 149-157. In this paper both the golden mean and random Cantor sets were involved on a very fundamental level. Later on El Naschie considered summing over two and three Stein spaces as well as exceptional Lie groups. This led to the discovery that the sum of the dimension of these Stein spaces is 5 multiplied with the inverse fine structure constant 137. This means 685 which is the dimension of the conjectured E12 exceptional Lie group. The second discovery was that the sum of all of the E-line exceptional Lie groups is equal to 4 multiplied by 137 which is 548. Having spoken so strongly against numerology and number coincidence we fear we could be giving a wrong impression about the role of number theory and number coincidence in physics. It was not only the well known Cambridge Professor Sir Arthur Stanley Edington who was deeply engaged in what many suspected of being numerology in his fundamental theory. In fact Nobel Laureate of Physics of the caliber of Paul Dirac we well as more recently Steven Weinberg were considering Eddington’s work and certain large number coincidence. Even more surprisingly Richard Feynman had great interest in the work of Eddington but he was talked out of it, probably by his friend Herbert C. Corben around 1942 as recounted in the autobiography of Feynman “The Beat of a Different Drum” by J. Mihra (Oxford 1994).
There are many excellent papers written by members of the E-infinity group explaining what is numerology and what is not. For instance L. Marek-Crnjac “On the vital difference between number theory and numerology in physics”, CS&F, 38 (2008), p. 1239-1242 as well as the paper by Ting Zhong “From the numerics of dynamics to the dynamics of numerics and visa versa in high energy particle physics”, CS&F, 42 (2009), p. 1780-1783. Next we would like to briefly mention the paper of Prof. A. Mukhamedov of Kazan University, Russia which connects E-infinity with the fiber bundle mentioned by Lisi. This paper is entitled “E-infinity as a fiber bundle and its thermodynamics”, CS&F, 33 (2007), p. 717-724.
Finally we have to again consider the embedding of E8 in the context of E-infinity which was strangely not taken up by Lisi although the view point was communicated to him in many comments years ago. The point is that once we embed E8 with its 248 dimensions in the 26 bosonic dimensions of string’s spacetime, we find that 248 + 26 = 274. Taking a shadow world like E8 E8 sper symmetry theory then we find (2)(274) = 548 which is exactly 4 times 137 found earlier on in summing over all exceptional Lie symmetry groups. There is an even more striking embedding this time with the kissing number of all the E-line exceptional groups. The sum of these kissing numbers is 522 and embedding in 26 leads to 522 + 26 = 548 exactly as above. This kissing number which may be interpreted physically as the contact point of hyper-sphere packing could be thought of as a tangible geometrical picture for the massless gauge boson of higher order theory of particle physics. Thank you.
E-infinity Group.

Dec 3, 2010

3rd December, 2010.
E-infinity Communication No. 40.
The new article by Garrett Lisi et al in Scientific American, December 2010 and the work of the E-infinity Group on E8 exceptional Lie groups.
The first article which appeared on the arXiv by garret Lisi entitled ‘An exceptionally simple theory of everything’ dated 6th November, 2007. This article seems to have been recommended on the arXiv by Prof. Lee Smolin working at that time intensively on establishing the Parameter Inst. Waterloo, Canada. Subsequent to the publication and unprecedented media hype followed mainly due to an article in the Telegraph. There was an enormous publicity and controversy. A second article followed in the Telegraph. The first article in the Telegraph announced that Garrett Lisi is the new Einstein. The second article announced that he is no Einstein. Of course all that has nothing to do with science. However scientists are sometimes, and maybe wrongly so, touchy about priority. They are also touchy about people using their work and not giving them credit. It is understandable to a point. Payment and everything worldly in science is very little. The main thing which remains for scientists is reputation, a sense of being appreciated and the hope that they will be remembered for their scientific contributions. It is really not much to ask when you think about the benefits and financial gain which other people make of science. Commercial publishers alone make billions in profit from publishing scientific work. The people who invented computers died in poverty. Computer companies are multi-national billion dollar enterprises. The guy who invented the internet is anything but a millionaire. Do not ask how much Google earns a day. For this reason maybe it is not unreasonable that there was a great deal of controversy about Lisi’s paper not giving credit to anyone who used E8, his exceptional Lie symmetry group. String theoreticians used it long ago. Of course they used it differently. To super strings, E8 E8 gives an otherwise non-super symmetric theory super symmetry and that way they get rid of many contradictions and maladies which the 26 dimensional Bosonic theory possesses. Lisi however uses E8 itself. He did not need to refer to strings, quantum gravity loops or any other physical model. The only model he had was the model of E8 itself only which is a pure geometrical model. Well you could argue that any model is at the end a mathematical model. That is true but Lisi did not invent any model, physical or mathematical. He simply took over the mathematical model of E8 as established by a mathematician thinking about mathematical structures with little if any physical thoughts in the back of their mind. Some critics thought that this is the ingenuity of Lisi. Other critics thought that this is the naivety of Lisi. You can argue any way you like. It is however a fact that one of the principle members of our group, Prof. M.S. El Naschie did the same thing within E-infinity theory long ago around 2004. Other members, for instance Prof. Marek-Crnjac and Prof. He as well as Prof. Iovane also considered the exceptional Lie group in a far wider context than Lisi and this was before Lisi published his paper. Referring explicitly to E8 and publishing papers with E8 in the title was also done long before Lisi. For instance one of the early papers on E-line exceptional Lie group was published in Int. J. of Nonlinear Sci. & Num. Simulation, 8(3), p. 445-450 (2007), entitled ‘Exceptional Lie groups hierarchy and the structure of the micro universe’. This is several months before the appearance of the first paper by Lisi on the arXiv. From the end of 2006 to roughly the time when Lisi published his paper on 6th November, 2007 Prof. El Naschie and his group published more than a dozen papers on the exceptional Lie groups and its application and physics and cosmology. He also recognized many things which are now coming to play a role in the newest of Lisi’s paper in Scientific American entitled ‘A geometric theory of everything’, December 2010. Needless to say, Lisi did not acknowledge any work of Prof. El Naschie or our group not in 2007 and not now although it is absolutely clear from even a superficial reading of his newest article in Scientific American that he benefited from the publications of the E-infinity group. This is of course very regrettable but it is not the end of the world and we take it in the same spirit in which we took and endured many things before, mostly coming from the same sources. Before we turn our attention to the scientific mathematical part of our discussion, we must note with an even greater regret that Scientific American is not allowing many people to lodge comments on this site unless they are certain that there will be nothing in the comment revealing the connection to our work. In fact the Editors of Scientific American made a claim on behalf of Lisi which Dr. Lisi himself did not make, namely that Lisi pioneered what in their words they call ‘showcases striking patterns in particle physics’. This is quite unfair on behalf of whoever is responsible in Scientific American for writing that while ignoring the efforts of so many other people. Let us come now to scientific issues.
1. Lisi still does not recognize that there are 8 exceptional Lie symmetry groups and not only 5. He still thinks that the exceptional Lie symmetry groups are E8, E7, E6, F4, G2. The corresponding dimensions are 248, 133, 78, 52 and 14. This is wrong. There are 8 E-line exceptional Lie symmetry groups and when you add F4 and G2, then we have 10. However the E-line has only 8. El Naschie is not the first to find out this fact which is not well known. However El Naschie is the first to emphasize this fact and use it in physics. Lisi overlooks this because he does not appreciate the importance of what mathematicians call Dynkin diagrams. This is explained thoroughly in the following paper by Mohamed El Naschie ‘Exceptional Lie groups hierarchy and some fundamental high energy physics equations’, Vol. 35 (2008), p. 82-84, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals. This paper appeared on the net of Science Direct in 2007 before Lisi’s paper appeared. You can see clearly from this paper that there is an E5 which is identical to the unification group SO(10). In addition there is an E4 which is identical to the unification group SU(5). With unification we mean grand unification theories which only excludes gravity. The fact that these are exceptional groups is exciting and has many ramifications for E-infinity theory once they are extended transfinitely. It seems that the first person to notice that was Howard Georgi. The dimension of E5 is naturally 45 and that of E4 is 24 which matches the additional bosons of this unification theory. Later on El Naschie noticed that there is an E3, E2 and E1. Again based on the Dynkin program, E3 is nothing but SU(3) SU(2). It has a dimension 11. Then there is an E2 which is equal to SU(3) with the well known dimension 8 and finally we have E1 equal to U(1) with the dimension 1. All this may be found in many of El Naschie’s papers and there are a few nice summaries and review articles of which we give the following: Symmetry group prerequisite for E-infinity in high energy physics, CS&F, 35 (2008), p. 202-211, Average exceptional Lie and Coxeter group hierarchies with special reference to the standard model of high energy particle physics, CS&F, 37 (2008), p. 662-668, High energy physics and the standard model from the exceptional Lie groups, CS&F, 36 (2008), p. 1-17. All these papers were published on Science Direct at the beginning of 2007.
2. The most remarkable thing about the hierarchy of the E-line of exceptional Lie groups is that the sum of all its dimensions is exactly four multiplied with the inverse of the electromagnetic fine structure constant 137. This is by no means numerology. It shows that electromagnetism is an averaging over symmetries. We know from Feynman’s path integral that you can sum over paths. This could be extended to summing over topologies as used by many mathematical physicists. The same idea could be extended to summing over Lie symmetry groups. El Naschie is the first to find this explicit result. Please try it yourself and see that 248 + 133 + 78 + 45 + 24 + 11 + 8 + 1 = 548 = 4 multiplied with 137. To show that this has nothing to do with numerology is very simple. Just use the transfinite version of all these numbers. A transfinite version is always an integer plus a transfinite tail represented by an irrational number. The number of digits fixing an irrational number is infinitely large. Because of that, to fit together by a mere numerical coincidence would require a probability which is exactly equal to zero. A numerical coincidence is by virtue of this transfinite nature exclusive as an impossible event. There are far more physically accessible explanations for why this is not numerology. It is not numerology because there are theories behind it . The theory behind it also has another theory behind it. And all these theories fit together seamlessly. If this agreement is coincidence and numerology, then it would be advisable to study only the science of numerology, a proposition which we definitely refute.
3. Lisi acknowledges in his newest paper SO(10) and gives it a prominent place but he does not recognize or mention that it is equivalent to E5. The same may be said about SU(5) which he does not recognize as E4. However he follows an Italian colleague of his in appreciating SO(11) which he made only recently and is mentioned again in an article in Scientific American under the title ‘Rummaging for a final theory, September 2010. The first suggestion which makes use in this context of SO(11) came however from El Naschie. It is well documented in the literature on the subject. For instance in his paper From E-eight to E-infinity, CS&F, 35 (2008), p. 285-290 El Naschie draws attention to SO(11) with a dimension 55 which plays an important role in finding the total number of particles in the standard model as well as playing a role in Edward Witten’s 5-Bran theory with 528 particle-like states. Lisi does not make full use of these facts but he partially makes use of it.
4. Lisi never spoke about fiber bundles except in his last paper. Of course we appreciate very much fiber bundle theory because it is mathematically well developed. We dare however to say that transfinite set theory is far more mathematically developed and far more fundamental. Consequently fractals are far more developed and far more fundamental than fiber bundles. In fact fiber bundles is not simple enough nor is it complex enough. It moves from smooth manifold to somewhat hairy manifold. However it does not go to infinity like fractals. In a sense it is a middle of the way approach. In a sense it is not fish nor meat but something in between. We most definitely think that the natural geometry and the most sophisticated geometry required by high energy physics is fractals. That is to say transfinite set theory interpreted geometrically.
There are many other things which we would like to talk about but we leave that for future communications. Thank you.
E-infinity Group.

Misconception spreading about Wheeler foam being a fractal

2nd December, 2010.

E-infinity Communication No. 39
Misconception spreading about Wheeler foam being a fractal
This communication is prompted by a fundamental misconception among theoretical physicists not really specialized in nonlinear dynamics and fractals who think that the Wheeler foam is a fractal. Of course there is no mathematical definition for what Wheeler foam is except that it is multi-connected and not simply connected space and in addition that such structure is a consequence of the vacuum fluctuation and that happens near to the Planck length. The mistake or misconception would be harmless if it would not lead to excellent physicists thinking wrongly that fractals exist only at the Planck length and are therefore relevant only to quantum gravity. This is completely wrong. In fact highly sophisticated theoretical physicists who also know about fractals mathematically, such as the singularly clever Gerard ‘t Hooft told Prof. El Naschie on several occasions that fractals are irrelevant for quantum mechanics. When he asked why is it used by some of his collaborators, he answered this is only maybe relevant for quantum gravity at the Planck length. For this reason it is obvious that we need to clarify this point.
First we should say that most of those working outside our group and the group of Prof. Nottale and Prof. Ord mention fractals but do not generally use much of what the powerful theory of fractal sets offers. They may occasionally use a Hausdorff dimension or some kind of fractal dimension to specify an important point here or there, but they do not really use the powerful machinery of transfinite set theory and transfinite theory of dimensions. The exception here is without a trace of a doubt is Prof. Alain Connes. Mathematically speaking Alain Connes’ noncommutative geometry is the most powerful and also the most complex machinery known to our trade. Alain Connes knew that fractals exist long before one reaches the Planck length. Fractals mean zero and empty sets. Any mechanics will somehow incorporate zero and empty sets. Some physics can muddle through without these concepts being said clearly from the outset. Other physical disciplines would be a muddle without a clear conception of the set theoretical basis, namely zero set and empty set. Quantum mechanics is such a physical subject which would be hopelessly complicated to understand without clear understanding of the role of the empty and the zero set.
Let us try to go into the historical reason of how this misconception came about. When Wheeler drew a picture of metric fluctuation due to vacuum fluctuation, it looked like foam. Some people called it Wheeler foam. Somehow it entered into the book of Mandelbrot, ‘The fractal geometry of nature’. Mandelbrot calculated the fractal dimension for a cube made of 27 smaller cubes when we iteratively remove the core cube. In other words, we get a fractal dimension equal to ln26 divided by ln3 which is 2.9656. For comparison the Menger sponge has a dimension equal to ln20 divided by ln3 which equals 2.7… From now on the misconception multiplies. Since it is now called fractal foam it is a fractal and since it is the foam of Wheeler, it is connected to metric fluctuation at the Planck length. Forgive us for saying this is complete nonsense. This misunderstanding crept into the work of some of the best and

Dec 2, 2010

Nobel laureate ‘tHooft’s recent incorporation of fractals

30th November, 2010.
E-infinity Communication No. 38
Nobel laureate ‘tHooft’s recent incorporation of fractals.
It is extremely interesting, in fact more than that, that Prof. ‘tHooft probably one of the most important high energy physicists of our time made several contacts with fractals recently. To appreciate the importance of these contacts for the task of incorporating nonlinear dynamics and deterministic chaos properly in high energy physics cannot be over emphasized. It is simply a fact of life that most if not all of the main stream high energy physics completely misunderstands fractals and have only a cocktail party appreciation of deterministic chaos. They simply do not think it is relevant to what they are doing. The present communication is not concerned in the first instance with the work of the group around Prof. ‘tHooft, for instance Prof. Loll and her associates. It is also not concerned with Prof. ‘tHooft’s proposal for a deterministic quantum mechanics. The new development is more concrete than all of that. To help the reader follow the discussion here we refer explicitly to a 2008 paper by Prof. ‘tHooft entitled ‘A locally finite model for gravity’. A version of this paper is freely available on ArXiv. Again to help the reader concentrate on the subtle points we refer explicitly to certain passages in this remarkable paper.
1. In the Abstract on page 1 Prof. ‘tHooft says “…. Globally however the model is not finite because solution tends to generate infinite fractals….. this model is not yet quantized”.
2. On page 2 he says “… however a confrontation with fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics appears to be inevitable….one can study systems with many particles by viewing spacetime as tissilation”.
3. On page 3 he says “… particles and strings as topological defects”.
4. On page 5 he says “… angles deficit and angles surplus…”.
5. On page 22 in the Conclusion ‘tHooft says “… strings could terminate in infinitely dense fractals of string segments where they could close the universe”.
Clearly Prof. ‘tHooft who appears from his Home Page to have appreciated the beauty and the mathematics of fractals some time ago has started to appreciate the profound relevance of fractals in physics. We would be extremely honored if this considerable change of heart on behalf of one of the most important physicists of our time was brought about by the dedicated work of the E-infinity group which was initiated by the wonderful work of Garnet Ord, Laurent Nottale and their colleagues.
The point about infinity and fractals is particularly relevant. If you want to have points and yet escape all the philosophical, mathematical unpleasant features of points including the production of infinities, then you have one thing, completely disconnected fractals which means Cantor sets. Of course you can use continuous fractals but then you are carrying unnecessary ballast. As Jim Yorke emphasized, the backbone of any nonlinear dynamics is always a Cantor set. Everything is something multiplied with a Cantor set. In his theory Mohamed El Naschie stripped everything down to Cantor sets and that way he can avoid infinity without resorting to finite stringy objects. In addition you have all the rigorous theorems connected to transfinite set theory and the transfinite theory of dimension at your disposal. Oscar Wilde used to say the best way to get rid of temptation is to give in to it. In a sense that is what fractals do. The best thing to get rid of the unpleasant infinities is work them and not to try to bar them out of the analysis. You have to accept that they are there. You have to tame them. The great Russian set theoretician tamed wild topology by understanding its transfinite set theoretical basis. It turns out that the topology of high energy physics is wild topology. It all ramifies into a dense Cantor set. ‘tHooft is rephrasing what we said here in a homomorphic language. Tissilation stands for fractal tiling such as Penrose universe. The boundary of El Naschie’s interpretation of ‘tHooft’s holographic boundary is indeed a dense fractal. At the end it is a Cantor set. You can iterated string segments, frogs or elephants , at the end you end with a Cantor set closing the universe. In E-infinity El Naschie as well as Crnjac showed that the 336 degrees of freedom of a Klein modular curve increases to around 339 due to compactification at infinity and that is what Prof. ‘tHooft was saying in his conclusion. It remains only to mention that the golden mean binary is naturally quantized. In addition fractals are naturally self-similar or at least self-affined. In other words fractals are naturally scale invariant due to the lack of natural states. In a fractal spacetime Weyl’s ideas are valid and Einstein’s objections against them are no longer valid. We sincerely hope that Prof. ‘tHooft will continue in this direction which we are certain is feasible and promising for the future of high energy physics.
E-infinity Group

Oct 4, 2010

E-Infinity 35 & 36 & 37

Welcome Address
Ji-Huan He /Chairman of 2010 ISND



Dear distinguished gathering, ladies and gentlemen
I am immensely pleased and honored to welcome you to Shanghai, which has been developing
very fast, and will be strongly impressed on your memory.
2010 ISND is organized as a preeminent event for nonlinear science community and other science communities as well. It is a great pleasure and honor for Donghua University to host this very important conference.
It provides me the greatest honor and pleasure to address you at this very important event, the
2010 ISND conference which is intended to bring together researchers from the industry and academia to discuss theory and applications of deterministic chaos and fractal geometry across natural as well as man-made sciences.
We have come a long way since our major conference of 2005. This time we have again a very
special reason to mark E-infinity theory as a special topic in this conference. There are various more than compelling reasons to do that. We may mention in particular the experimental discovery and verification of the golden mean in quantum mechanics by the Helmholtz Centre in Germany in cooperation with the University of Oxford. This hard to overestimate experimental fact is exactly what was predicted by E-infinity theory almost two decades ago. With this experimental confirmation this matter and any genuine controversy are largely settled. Any objective researcher must from now on take it as an indisputable fact that nonlinear dynamics and chaos which manifest themselves geometrically as fractals and Cantor sets provide the missing link between the quantum and the non-quantum relativistic world.
Our group has worked with considerable dedication on this fundamental cutting edge research and made some of the most important contributions to this theory. In particular we were able to establish in the clearest of forms the relationship between the transfinite theory of dimensions and fractals as well as the physical meaning of the empty set of the Menger-Urysohn theory. The golden ratio in this context is of course the finger print of the KAM theorem as well as being the Hausdorff dimension of a Mauldin-Williams random triadic Cantor set. It is also the backbone of A. Connes dimensional function of his noncommutative geometry with its well known relation to quantum mechanics. All of that will be explained in detail at this conference in various invited and contributed papers. For this reason we are extremely happy that the Egyptian engineering scientist and theoretical physicist, Professor M.S. El Naschie accepted our invitation to come to Shanghai especially from London despite his health condition to deliver the opening lecture of this conference.
Unification theory has been working for many years, but rare focus was put on the unification of
Newton Mechanics and Quantum mechanics: Newton’s mechanics is deterministic; while Quantum mechanics is probabilistic, they are two sides of a contradiction, no one considered to unify the two contrary theories. Fortunately, we have now ancient Chinese philosophy of Tai Chi. According to this philosophy, Prof. C.D. Yang proposed a new space called the complex space, and his complex mechanics has caught much attention. From this complex space, quantum mechanics can be simply derived the complex-extended Newtonian mechanics. Great classics when revisited in the light of modern physics , especially nonlinear dynamics may reveal hidden pearls. For this reason we are extremely happy that Professor C.D. Yang accepted our invitation to come to Shanghai to deliver the opening lecture of this conference and introduce the complex mechanics.
It is not unusual for any revolutionary idea to provoke a counter-revolutionary reaction.
E-infinity is a revolutionary idea building upon many other revolutionary ideas like M. Feigenbaum’s universalities, B. Mandelbrot’s fractals and A. Connes’ noncommutative geometry. However these are all scientific revolutions and not political, social revolutions. Opposing such scientific revolutions should only take the form of scientific debates and arguments. To explain what I mean let me recount to you what Werner Heisenberg lamented about the attacks by many notable scientists including Nobel laureates in physics on A. Einstein calling his theory of relativity, Semitic non-aryan physics. Heisenberg said he was extremely saddened by the fact that the attacks were not scientific attacks but politically motivated, dishonest attacks. Later on when a book published with the title ‘A hundred scientists against Einstein’, the great man remarked: “Why one hundred? If I were wrong, one would be sufficient.”
We hope that this conference will allow the rest of our scientific community to realize the new and powerful possibilities which nonlinear dynamics, deterministic chaos and fractal geometry provides to not only round up our picture of nature and reality and resolve long outstanding quantum paradoxes such as the two-slit experiment with quantum particles and the wave collapses, but will also give us a handle on useful applications in nano and other new technologies. I sincerely hope you will find the conference enjoyable and the discussions illuminating and useful. I hope also that you will foster new scientific friendships, helping you in your research.
Hereby, I should express my thanks to Donghua University for their sponsorship of this
conference.
It is my greatest honor to invite Prof. M.S. El Naschie and Dr. C.D. Yang to give our audience
important plenary lectures, which present an overview of the current status of their fields with a speculative outlook on what are to come out in the future, making the conference accessible to a broad audience. I also appreciate very much all reviewers for their time and help and mini-symposium organizers, without their help, the success of the conference will be impossible.
As pointed out by Einstein, “The most incomprehensible thing about the world is that it is at all
comprehensible”, but how do we fully understand incomprehensible things? This conference provides various useful clues. I can ensure you that it will be a mathematically enriching and socially exciting event.